Back to ResourcesThe Bottom Line
AI agents — ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews — are now reading websites on behalf of users. They're comparing businesses against competitors. And they're deciding who to recommend.
60% of Google searches now show AI Overviews. Only 8% of people click through to a website when they appear. But here's the flip side: businesses showing up in AI recommendations are seeing 10-21x conversion rates. Fewer visitors, but the right visitors.
Almost nobody is optimizing for this yet. That's your window.
The Shift: AI Is Your Website's Most Important Visitor
For the first time ever, it's not just humans looking at your website — it's AI. ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews — these systems are reading your site, comparing you against competitors in real time, and making recommendations.
No one is doing this correctly yet. That means you can get so far ahead of your competition right now that by the time they figure it out, you're untouchable. I call this AI Agent Optimization (AAO) — and it's the new game.
The old playbook was: rank for keywords, get clicks, hope people convert. The new playbook is: give AI everything it needs to confidently recommend you over everyone else.
The Data: What's Actually Happening to Search
The numbers are hard to ignore.
The Traffic Collapse
| Company | Traffic Impact |
|---|---|
| HubSpot | Lost 75-85% of web traffic |
| Business Insider | Lost 55%+ of organic traffic |
| HuffPost & Forbes | Traffic cut in half |
| The Planet D (travel blog) | Lost half its traffic, ceased publication entirely |
HubSpot CEO Yamini Rangan put it bluntly:
"AI overviews are giving answers, and fewer people are clicking through to websites."
Google AI Overviews reached 2 billion monthly users as of Q2 2025. Coverage expanded from 6.49% of queries in January 2025 to 60% by November. When AI Overviews appear, organic CTR crashes 61% and paid CTR crashes 68%. Only 1% of users click a link within an AI Overview — most just read the answer and leave.
The Conversion Flip Side
Here's what most people miss: while total traffic is dropping, conversion quality is going through the roof.
| Source | Finding |
|---|---|
| Ahrefs | AI referrals = 0.5% of traffic but drove 12.1% of signups (23x better conversion) |
| Adobe | AI-referred visitors 43% less likely to bounce, spent 41% longer on site, converted at 2x+ rate |
| ChatGPT | Sent 1.2 billion outgoing referrals in a single quarter, surpassing Reddit and LinkedIn |
Let that sink in. Maybe your search results are going down. Who cares? AI is allowing the RIGHT people to find you — fewer visitors but the right visitors. That's the reframe.
Two Audiences: AI and Humans
Your website now has two audiences: AI and humans. Most businesses only think about the first one.
Humans need your site to look professional, feel trustworthy, and work smoothly. That hasn't changed.
AI agents need something completely different: comprehensive information, clean code structure, and content they can actually read and understand. A human might spend 30 seconds scanning your homepage. An AI can go through your entire site in seconds — but only if the content is accessible.
If you're only optimizing for humans, you're invisible to the fastest-growing source of high-converting referrals.
The JavaScript Problem: Why Your "Beautiful" Website Might Be Invisible
This is the one that catches people off guard. JavaScript often can't be read by AI.
Most AI crawlers don't execute JavaScript at all. If your content loads dynamically — through animations, fancy transitions, or client-side rendering — AI sees an empty page. Literally nothing.
I see so many websites built to be cool. The animations are beautiful, everything slides in, fades up. But if you have an animation that goes from opacity 0 to 100, the AI doesn't wait for that. It sees nothing.
Vercel analyzed 569 million GPTBot requests and confirmed: ChatGPT, Claude, and Perplexity crawlers fetch JavaScript but never render it. If your content isn't in the initial HTML, it doesn't exist to AI.
Template websites from Wix, Squarespace, and other builders are often the worst offenders. They look the same to AI — nothing to differentiate you. AI crawlers operate under tight 3-5 second timeout budgets. If your site is slow to respond, they abandon entirely.
The fix: Server-side rendering (SSR) or static site generation. Your content needs to be in the raw HTML before any JavaScript runs.
The 7-Point Framework
This is the actionable part. Seven things you can do right now to make AI pick you over your competitors.
1. Content Depth
You want a ton of content on your website. Not surface-level fluff — real, comprehensive answers to every question someone in your industry might ask.
I had a client in pressure washing. We wrote detailed blogs about humidity and how it affects pressure washing formulas, what chemicals to use on different surfaces, seasonal timing guides. I don't think anyone wants to read that. It's not for humans — it's for the AI.
AI goes through your blog posts to determine if you know what you're talking about, if you're up to date. When someone asks "who's the best pressure washer near me," the AI thinks: "Stu at power washing knows his stuff — we're gonna put him at the top."
The data backs this up:
| Factor | Impact |
|---|---|
| Pages with original data tables | 4.1x more AI citations |
| Content updated within 3 months | Significantly better performance |
| Sites with 50+ referring domains | 5x more AI traffic |
| Clear heading hierarchies | 40% more likely to be cited |
2. Own the Comparisons
AI is constantly comparing businesses. When someone asks "compare Company A to Company B," the AI looks for that information. If your competitor has a comparison page and you don't — guess who gets recommended?
Put a comparison on YOUR site. Be honest about it. For the first time, you can hand-feed AI everything it needs to make sure that you are number one. Don't let competitors control the narrative.
Frame it as "here's how we're different from X" — honest comparison, not trash talk. Give the AI the exact information it needs to recommend you.
3. Pricing Transparency
I don't know why so many companies don't offer pricing on their website. If you hide your pricing, you're invisible for every query where budget matters.
AI can't recommend you for "affordable" or "best value" if you don't put it out there. Guess who can't compare you? The AI. Guess who's gonna show up? The competitor who does show pricing.
You don't need to show exact pricing for every custom project. But ranges, starting points, or package tiers give AI something to work with.
4. Clean Backend + llms.txt
A clean backend — not a bunch of animations and fancy effects. If you have websites built by templated page builders, they all look the same to AI. How do you stand out?
llms.txt is a new standard — a file specifically for AI to read your site. Think of it like robots.txt but for language models. It's a markdown file formatted specifically for LLM consumption. If you don't have one, you're immediately at a disadvantage.
The llms.txt standard was proposed by Jeremy Howard in September 2024 and has been adopted by 600+ websites including Anthropic, Stripe, and Cloudflare.
Other technical factors that matter:
| Technical Factor | Impact |
|---|---|
| Schema markup (JSON-LD) | Increases AI citations by ~28% |
| Most impactful schema types | FAQPage, LocalBusiness, HowTo, Organization |
Semantic HTML (<article>, <section>) | Helps crawlers understand content boundaries |
| Proper H1 → H2 → H3 hierarchy | Signals relationships between ideas |
You want a custom website built from the ground up for AI, making it as easy as possible for AI to go through every page.
5. Show Your Expertise (E-E-A-T)
Showing your expertise is beyond important. Here's the thing: blogs are kind of dead — but they're not, because of AI agents.
AI reads your blog posts to determine if you're an expert. They go through your content to see: do you know what you're talking about? Are you up to date? We do whole blogs for our clients because AI agents read them. We don't even care if humans read them.
The research is clear: content from authors with established expertise is cited 340% more frequently than anonymous content, according to the GEO-BENCH study from Princeton.
E-E-A-T stands for Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, and Trustworthiness. Show it by:
- Putting your name on things with real credentials
- Writing from direct experience, not generic summaries
- Including case studies with specific results
- Adding detailed bios with qualifications
6. Answer Capsules
When you have a question as a heading, put a clear, quotable answer right after it. 20-30 words max — that's what AI pulls and quotes. Give it to the AI.
Frame your headings as questions people actually ask, then answer them directly in the first sentence or two.
The data: 72.4% of posts cited by ChatGPT contained concise, self-contained explanations (answer capsules). The optimal capsule length is 120-150 characters placed directly after question-framed headings.
One more thing: 91% of cited answer capsules contained no links. Links in the capsule itself may dilute quotability. Place supporting links in later paragraphs, not in the capsule.
7. Local SEO Still Matters
If you're a local service business — good news. Google still doesn't show AI Overviews for local searches. They explicitly removed them because AI results are "vague, lack images, and often list places that aren't even nearby."
Google Business Profile, reviews, local SEO — that still works. Those still matter. I'm not taking any of that away.
Here's the power move: if you can get people to write reviews that answer questions, even better. Reviews that say "here's why they're the best" give AI specific reasons to recommend you.
One vision correction practice achieved top positions in map pack, organic, AND AI Overviews — and reported a 20% increase in business within 4-5 months. NAP consistency (Name, Address, Phone) across all platforms is still critical.
The Window Is Closing
The window is closing, but we still have a little bit of time. This is when you can really get ahead.
| Prediction | Source |
|---|---|
| 25% decline in traditional search volume by 2026 | Gartner |
| AI search visitors may surpass traditional search by 2028 | Semrush |
| AI Mode will be Google's default search experience | Barry Schwartz |
| Traffic projections should be cut in half in 2026 | Lily Ray (Amsive) |
| 50% of top-cited AI content is less than 13 weeks old | Recency bias research |
We're not gaming the system. We're just providing what we need to provide — comprehensive, well-structured content that both humans and AI can understand.
Most businesses have no idea this shift happened. They're still thinking about SEO the way it worked three years ago. First movers win. By the time everyone catches on, it'll be too late.
Success Stories
Early adopters are already seeing results:
- Industrial manufacturer: Zero to 2,300% AI traffic increase by optimizing for E-E-A-T + schema markup
- Agency Xponent21: 4,162% traffic growth and top Perplexity citations within three weeks by adding schema
- Software company: 45% increase in qualified leads within six months by restructuring content around conversational queries
The ONE Thing to Do
Go ask ChatGPT to compare you to your competitors right now. See what comes up. If the answer isn't what you want it to be — that's your starting point.
Then:
- Run the free audit — use our AI website audit tool to see how your site scores against these exact criteria
- Fix the technical foundation — make sure your content is server-rendered, add llms.txt, implement schema markup
- Build content depth — start answering every question your customers ask, even the obscure ones
The shift from "ranking for keywords" to "being worth citing" is the biggest change in digital marketing in a decade. But it's not about tricks — it's about genuinely having a website that's structured well and has comprehensive, useful content.
Want help optimizing your website for AI agents? Run the free audit or book a strategy call and we'll map out exactly what needs to change.
